Margaret Fuller by Megan Marshall

In PAPERBACK, December 5, 2017


Elizabeth Bishop:
A Miracle
for BrEakfast

By Megan Marshall

Praise | Q & A

From a Pulitzer Prize-winning author, a brilliantly rendered life of one of our most admired American poets

Since her death in 1979, Elizabeth Bishop, who published only one hundred poems in her lifetime, has become one of America’s most revered poets. And yet—painfully shy and living out of public view in far-flung locations like Key West and Brazil—she has never been seen so fully as a woman and artist. Megan Marshall makes incisive and moving use of a newly discovered cache of Bishop’s letters—to her psychiatrist and to three of her lovers—to reveal a much darker childhood than has been known, a secret affair, and the last chapter of her passionate romance with Brazilian modernist designer Lota de Macedo Soares.

These elements of Bishop’s life, along with her friendships with fellow poets Marianne Moore and Robert Lowell, both important champions of her work, are brought to life with novelistic intensity. And by alternating the narrative line of biography with brief passages of memoir, Megan Marshall, who studied with Bishop in her storied 1970s poetry workshop at Harvard, offers the reader an original and compelling glimpse of the ways poetry and biography, subject and biographer, are entwined.


"Elegant, moving...this new biography fuses sympathy with intelligence, sending us back to Bishop’s marvelous poems."
The Wall Street Journal (Read Review)

“...a biography which at last illuminates one of America’s finest, and most elusive, poets."
The Economist (Read Review)

“Marshall’s account is lively and engaging, charged with vindicating energy. . . . The book is ultimately about how words ordered on a page may supply some order for one’s life, may assuage and even redeem tragedy.”  
—Claudia Roth Pierpont, New Yorker (Read Review)

Elizabeth Bishop:  A Miracle for Breakfast…helps fill in for devotees of Bishop’s work much of what couldn’t fit into one of her painstakingly perfected poems.  And what we learn from Marshall’s book—informed by a mother lode of newly discovered letters—is that none of Bishop’s accomplishments could ever ease the pain of her loneliness...One advantage that Marshall has in telling Bishop’s story is her access to a trove of previously unavailable letters, which reveal the poet’s more intimate and personal side—the very facts that she guarded so zealously from others…Marshall utilizes this new material with elegance and craft worthy of her subject.” 
—David Yaffe, The Nation

“A biography that is at heart about the art of writing, the way that scholarship and research (as much as poetry) can offer a way to integrate losses that might be otherwise too overwhelming and painful to bear.”
—Kim Phillips-Fein, author of Fear City, in “Top Authors of 2017 Pick their Favorite Books,” Publishers Weekly (Read review)

“Like all great biographies, this one reads something like a novel, with a depth of characterization, intensity of description (especially of inner states), and vigorous narrative momentum that are literary in their own right.  A deeply humane critic, Marshall’s . . . readings of Bishop’s lyrics are astute (and mercifully concise), while her portrait of the poet as a human being left me feeling as though I’d met her, even struck up a friendship. Pulling deeply from Bishop’s archives, especially the treasure chest of letters and drafts at Vassar College, Marshall demonstrates how the poems bubbled up and evolved in the writer’s notebooks, and manages to elucidate without becoming tendentious. She never subjects Bishop’s life or work to a monolithic, final interpretation; nor is either truly background or foreground, but both at once in Marshall’s deft handling. It is the best biography of Bishop available and will be for a long time.”
—Ryan Boyd, Dialogist (Read Review)

“Marshall…vividly dramatize[s] the mysterious relationship between personal suffering and art.”
The Atlantic

“A skillful and judicious performance . . . without any of the stiffness, the blockiness or monumentality that sometimes afflicts biography.”
—Michael Hofmann, TLS

“This smooth and brisk presentation by a Pulitzer Prize-winning biographer of one of America’s most accomplished poets is enriched by recently discovered documents. Interweaving her own experience as a student of Bishop’s in the 1970s, Marshall skillfully discerns echoes between Bishop’s public and private writing.”
—The New York Times (Read Review)

“Megan Marshall's brilliant new book Elizabeth Bishop: A Miracle for Breakfast, presents in alternate chapters Marshall's tremendously empathetic biography of her former teacher and her own memoir of her years intersecting with Bishop in Boston and Cambridge. This combined approach creates a stunningly effective portrait of the famously elusive Bishop."Christian Science Monitor

“[Marshall] probes Bishop’s psychology, love life, and feelings about her contemporaries with surprising completeness. . . .   Until now, our knowledge of Bishop’s personal life has largely been limited to her fractured relationship with the Brazilian Lota [de Macedo Soares]. . . .  Marshall has unearthed more, some of it stunningly intimate.” 
—The Boston Globe (Read Review)

“Using a wealth of new material, including the poet’s letters to her lovers and psychoanalyst, Marshall has crafted the most intimate and accurate biography yet available.  Anyone interested in Bishop’s life and work will need to read this moving and often revelatory new account. . . .   Elizabeth Bishop: A Miracle for Breakfast is the rare sort of book that will expand the audience for contemporary poetry.”
— Dana Gioia, The American Scholar

“Marshall, whose earlier works include Margaret Fuller (winner of the 2014 Pulitzer Prize for Biography) and The Peabody Sisters, here uses newly discovered letters by Elizabeth Bishop (1911-79) to offer a broader view of the life of the poet (who published only around 100 poems in her lifetime). Marshall, who studied with Bishop during the 1970s at Bishop's poetry workshop at Harvard University, is able to give readers both an academic view of her subject as well as glimpses into the poet's personae. Marshall brings the sometimes elusive writer, who spent significant periods of her life in Key West and Brazil, to life, offering a cohesive and novel look at the ways in which subject and biographer are intertwined and the value of understanding a poet's biography while reading their work.  VERDICT: This study opens up a new way of looking at Bishop's life and her place in American letters. Recommended for poetry and literature lovers and fans of literary biography.
Library Journal

“A riveting account of Elizabeth Bishop's artful life, told in connection to the story of her own literary vocation, Marshall's book details two lives whose ‘precipitate and pragmatical’ intersection in the late 1970s was a windfall for American letters.”
—Heather Treseler, Worcester Telegram

"I really don't know HOW poetry gets to be written," Elizabeth Bishop once lamented, proposing some combination of mystery, surprise, and hard work. In a life marked by regular loss, inspiration would prove as elusive as happiness; the verse seemed to sneak up on her when she least expected. Megan Marshall here coaxes the self-conscious poet out of her shyness, her genius into words.  She proceeds as did Bishop in her best verse, by description paired with astute reflection.  And Marshall is daring, stepping out from behind the biographical curtain, effectively, ingeniously, and with a lovely twist at the end.  A sure-handed, beautifully constructed book that captures the color of Elizabeth Bishop's life–melancholy and ecstatic, anchored by whiskey and words, by turns New England grim and toucan-vibrant–on the page.  Megan Marshall performs her own miracle: Here is how poetry gets written.
—Stacy Schiff,  Pulitzer Prize-winning author of Véra, Cleopatra, and The Witches

"Elizabeth Bishop, the quietest, most elusive, and among the greatest of modern American poets, has since her death become a cultural icon, much studied, much quoted, and even a character in films and fiction. Now we have a remarkable book—part biography, part memoir—by a writer whose life actually intersected with hers. Megan Marshall, like her subject, has an unerring eye for the telling detail and the illuminating story. She succeeds in bringing Elizabeth Bishop vividly to life in all her poignant complexity."
—Lloyd Schwartz, Pulitzer Prize-winning critic, co-editor of Elizabeth Bishop: Poems, Prose, and Letters

"A new biography of one of the most celebrated American poets of the 20th century. Elizabeth Bishop (1911-1979) wasn't prolific—she published only 100 poems during her 40-year career—but she had a lasting impact on American letters. Pulitzer Prize winner Marshall was one of the aspiring poets Bishop taught in her final "verse-writing" class at Harvard in 1977. The experience was so profound that, upon discovering a trove of letters after Bishop's "close friend" Alice Methfessel died in 2009, Marshall set about to write this biography. The result is a sharp portrait of the tragedies and other influences that shaped Bishop's life and career. Bishop was only eight months old when her father died. After her mother was hospitalized for mental illness, Bishop was shuttled between her maternal grandparents in Nova Scotia, a place she loved, and her paternal grandparents in Worcester, Massachusetts. After these early scenes, Marshall documents Bishop's maturation as a writer; her struggles with alcoholism; her 17 years living in Brazil with her partner, architect Lota de Macedo Soares; her many affairs; and her relationships with such writers as Robert Lowell and Mary McCarthy. Best of all are Marshall's analyses of Bishop's poems, including "Song for the Rainy Season," "In the Waiting Room," and the book's subtitle. . . .  The chapters on Bishop are written with often chilling exactness, as when Marshall describes the uncle who drew young Elizabeth's bath and gave her "an unusually thorough washing" or the polio-stricken admirer who killed himself after Bishop rejected him. His suicide note read, "Elizabeth. Go to hell." Bishop shared with Marianne Moore a "near obsession with accuracy of detail and precision of language." This fine biography demonstrates the magnitude of Bishop's achievements without ignoring her flaws."
—Kirkus Reviews



Q & A

Is Elizabeth Bishop in need of a new biography?

Yes–most definitely! The last major biography of Elizabeth Bishop was published in the early 1990s, almost twenty-five years ago, when both biographer and readers weren’t quite ready for a book that was open about the personal life of a poet who was herself so private, so insistently closeted, even though she lived into the era of Gay Liberation. But I’m not “outing” Elizabeth Bishop. My goal was to learn how her one hundred poems (that’s all she published, she was so meticulous) fit into her life, to uncover their sources in particular moments and memories, even as her consummate craftsmanship, her instinctive originality, made her poetry timeless, universal, “immortal,” according to her great friend Robert Lowell.

Just as important as the changing times has been a cache of letters, Bishop’s most intimate correspondence, previously thought to be lost or destroyed, that was discovered after the death of her last lover, Alice Methfessel, in 2009. These letters made it possible to write with sympathy and precision about the end of Bishop’s long love affair–really a marriage–with Brazilian modernist designer Lota de Macedo Soares; to learn about the scary dysfunction in Bishop’s family life as a child and her teenage sexual awakening from a series of letters written to her psychoanalyst; to understand the profound attachment she felt for Alice Methfessel in a late-life second (or third or fourth!) sexual awakening that enabled her to write again after the calamitous breakup with Lota, who’d died of a drug overdose during an attempted reconciliation.

I don’t view any of this as prying–would anyone say it was prying or invasive to read and write about the love letters of Yeats or Joyce or any other major male poet or writer? Elizabeth Bishop is in that league, and her writing, often autobiographical, though rarely explicitly so, begs to be understood through the life.

Why the subtitle: “A Miracle for Breakfast”?

I love this title Elizabeth Bishop chose for the first of two sestinas she wrote, helping to make this centuries-old verse form popular again. It’s not a poem that’s easy to understand, but it contains everything that’s wonderful about Bishop’s poetry–the delight in everyday rituals, like drinking coffee at breakfast; the sense that, with close observation, tiny things can be hugely meaningful; and a wry acceptance that for most of us, as the poem concludes, “the miracle” might be “working,” but “on the wrong balcony.”

A passage in one of Elizabeth’s Bishop’s early journals reveals that she got the idea for the poem while living in Greenwich Village in the 1930s, shortly after graduating from Vassar. She was lonely, at loose ends, unsure of whether she’d make it as a poet, probably drinking too much. She’d woken up to find she had no food in her apartment, when she heard a call on the stairs–a representative of Wonder Bread bakeries was offering free slices of this brand new product. Suddenly she had something to eat, provided by a woman so down on her luck she’d taken a demeaning job passing out free samples for one of the few businesses that thrived in the Depression. Elizabeth titled this anecdote “A Little Miracle” in her journal, but it took three years and plenty of other experiences for the idea to become the poem, which actually has little to do with the original event.

Following Bishop’s imaginative process was thrilling, but this poem is also the one that John Ashbery, one of the great American poets of the next generation, chose to read at her memorial service forty years later in 1979. He loved it too. And the sestina form grabbed me. I saw how the words at the end of each line, repeated in a prescribed pattern through six stanzas of six lines each, could become chapter titles for the six biographical chapters in my book. Suddenly I started seeing those end words–balcony, crumb, coffee, river, miracle, sun–everywhere in Bishop’s writing, not just in the poetry, but also in the prose (she wrote some remarkable short stories) and correspondence.

Writing the book sometimes felt like writing a very long poem in prose, exacting and liberating at the same time, like “thinking with one’s feelings,” as Elizabeth Bishop said of the poet’s task. Using those words artfully became a challenge that kept me going through three years of intense work, beckoning me toward the end, where I was determined to find a way to work all six of them into a final sentence, as in the closing “Envoy” of a sestina.

You knew Elizabeth Bishop as your teacher in the 1970s. Did that make it more difficult to write an objective biography?

Although I took a writing workshop at Harvard, where I was a scholarship student, with Elizabeth Bishop–“Advanced Verse-Writing” was her name for the class–I didn’t know her well at all. Her classes were quite structured and formal, and she was very shy, not comfortable holding forth or dispensing wisdom. Some of her students became her friends, but I wasn’t one of them. In fact there was a little problem between us that plays out in the brief autobiographical sections that alternate with the longer biographical chapters of the book.

How well do we know the people in our lives? How well can a biographer know her subject, relying only on primary documents and remembered accounts? The alternating chapters of Elizabeth Bishop: A Miracle for Breakfast–biography followed by memoir followed by more biography–take on these questions indirectly. The reader sees Elizabeth Bishop as I knew her in real time, at the end of her life, alongside Elizabeth Bishop as she experienced her own life, going through it from birth to death.

One of the surprising results is that the reader gets closer to Elizabeth Bishop, experiencing her vicariously through my eyes. The essential mystery of what enables a person of genius to realize her talent is still there, but we see Elizabeth Bishop at first hand struggling to solve that problem. And it was a problem I struggled with too, how to make use of my own lesser capabilities and manage my fledgling ambitions as a student poet. We’ve all been there.

I learned so much from Miss Bishop, as we called her, that wasn’t on her syllabus, and that I’ve come to appreciate more powerfully since college and while writing this book. Miss Bishop taught by living her life, and so it seems natural that I would one day write her biography. Although lives aren’t pre-determined, they take their own course and may not really have a coherent shape, there was something miraculous about the reverberations in our lives that I began to feel as I worked on the book, and a coincidence that seemed to bring us together at the end.

Objectivity is always a relative matter in biography–the writer is either sympathetic to or in disagreement with her subject, or she wouldn’t put in the time. In this book, the stakes are clear, which made the work fascinating and draws back the veil for readers.

Do you have a favorite Elizabeth Bishop poem?

I loved writing about “One Art,” Elizabeth Bishop’s best known poem. There are seventeen drafts, so you can track the progression of her thoughts and feelings, witness her artistic decisions. And I learned more about the circumstances that inspired the poem: Elizabeth’s fear that she was losing Alice to a man she planned to marry. But “The Shampoo” has always been one of my favorites. It’s the most explicit love poem written for a woman that Elizabeth Bishop published (which means not very explicit). “The Shampoo” is about the way love infuses domestic ritual as she washes Lota’s long black hair, streaked with gray, on the patio outside the house they were building together on a mountainside in Brazil. (They had no indoor shower yet.) The poem ends with this beautiful, rhythmic, invitation:

–Come, let me wash it in this big tin basin,
battered and shiny like the moon.